EU parliament vote on hazardous substances sends 'clear signal'

 

Greens/EFA deputy Jill Evans, the European Parliament's rapporteur on the restriction of hazardous substances (RoHS) directive, said a committee vote on the draft law has sent a "clear signal" about the dangers of hazardous chemicals used in electrical and electronic equipment.

Evans said - "I am glad that, despite heavy pressure from the chemical industry, the committee has voted for certain problematic substances to be highlighted for further review and a possible ban."

MEPs on parliament's environment committee are arguing that some substances - including halogenated flame retardants and PVC - should undergo further assessments before they are used in electrical and electronic equipment. They agreed that the list of substances banned by directive should apply to all such equipment, unless specifically excluded.

"We know that substances - such as halogenated flame retardants, PVC and phthalates - can cause serious health and environmental problems during the treatment of electrical and electronic waste," said Evans, adding - "This should be the first step in phasing them out.

"A broad majority in the environment committee also voted for all electrical and electronic equipment to be covered by the directive. In addition, a more thorough exemption process has been adopted. Both these results closed serious loop-holes in the directive."

Reaction to the vote was swift with Rainer Hinrichs-Rahlwes, president of the European Renewable Energies Federation (EREF), saying it particularly welcomed the decision to reject the suggestion that renewable energy systems should be included in the scope of a directive.

He said - "This would have created another competitive disadvantage against renewable energies. It does not make sense to treat renewable energy technology - like windmills, heat pumps or solar panels - as if they were sandwich toasters or DVD-players.

"Renewables are competing with fossil and nuclear energy production and not with household equipment. We, therefore, welcome the decision to exclude renewable energies from the scope of RoHS."

However, the outcome of the committee vote was not universally welcomed. In a statement, Amcham and TechAmerica Europe said they were "very concerned" about the lack of an impact assessment of an ‘open scope’ that "would include all electrical and electronic equipment, cables, consumables and accessories.

James Lovegrove, managing director of TechAmerica Europe, said - “Our members are concerned by the support today to expand the scope to all electrical and electronic equipment without any sound environmental justification or impact assessment."

Plans to 'recast' the directive will go to a plenary vote in July in Strasbourg.