Shoe firm steps right into packaging fine

 

In the UK, the legal and financial risks of failing to comply with packaging regulations was underlined last week, when a major shoe retailer became the latest high profile firm to be hit with a fine for breaching waste rules.

Brantano - a footwear retailer with 147 stores in the UK - has been ordered to pay over £30,000 after it pleaded guilty to 15 charges related to not registering with the Environment Agency and not meeting its packaging waste requirements under the Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Regulations 1997, 2005 and 2007.

Under the rules, businesses that make, fill, sell or handle more than 50 tonnes of packaging a year and have a turnover of more than £2 million must register with the Environment Agency - either directly or through a producer compliance scheme, pay for the recovery and recycling of certain amounts of packaging waste and provide evidence that they have done so.

The firm managed to avoid costs of £20,000 by ignoring the regulations - and, as a result, has been fined £30,000.

The scale of the fine is likely to prompt from questions from environmental groups as to whether the penalties are high enough to discourage firms from avoiding their packaging and recycling obligations.

However, a spokeswoman for the Environment Agency insisted that fines were rising and firms that flouted the rules were at risk of tougher sentences. "Courts have been treating these cases with increasing severity recently, we would always welcome stiff sentences for this type of crime," she said.

Brantano is the latest in a series of firms to be found guilty of breaching producer responsibility obligations.

Earlier this month, the Great Western Wine Company was ordered to pay charges of more than £35,000 in fines and costs for not recycling its waste packaging, while drinks firm Red Bull received a record £261,268 fine last year for a similar offence. High profile hair straightener manufacturer, GHD, was also hit with a fine and costs totalling over £9,000 after claiming it was unaware of the rules.

Fines for packaging infringements have been ramped up over the last few years. In 2007 and 2008, around £700,000 worth of fines were paid in both years - up from over £470,000 in 2006 and £210,000 in 2005.